The Costly Mistakes Every New Landlord Makes (And How to Avoid Them)

Turning Your Arizona Investment into a Nightmare? Here's How to Avoid It

Being a landlord in Arizona seems simple enough: buy property, find tenants, collect rent, and profit. But ask any experienced property owner and they'll tell you—it's rarely that straightforward.

At KPI Realtors, we've seen promising investments quickly turn into money pits because of avoidable mistakes. Before you dive into DIY property management, consider these costly errors that plague new landlords in the Grand Canyon State.

1. The "Anyone Will Do" Tenant Screening Mistake

Eager to start generating income, many landlords rush through tenant screening or skip it altogether. That friendly couple with cash in hand might seem perfect, but without proper background checks, you could end up with tenants who:

• Have a history of late payments or evictions
• Cause extensive property damage
• Create legal headaches that cost thousands to resolve

The Arizona Reality: Our state's tenant screening laws require careful compliance with Fair Housing regulations while allowing landlords to establish reasonable criteria. Misunderstanding these rules can lead to discrimination claims or problematic tenants.

2. The "I Can Fix That" DIY Repair Trap

That leaky faucet seems simple enough to fix yourself, right? Many landlords underestimate the time, skill, and costs involved in property maintenance, leading to:

• Subpar repairs that require professional fixing later
• Safety hazards that create liability issues
• Emergency calls at 2 AM when the AC fails in July's 110-degree heat

The Arizona Reality: Our extreme desert climate creates unique maintenance challenges, from AC systems that must function flawlessly during scorching summers to monsoon-season water damage prevention.

3. The "Basic Coverage Is Fine" Insurance Gamble

Many new landlords choose minimal insurance coverage, not understanding how exposed this leaves them until it's too late. Inadequate insurance can be devastating when:

• A tenant is injured on your property and sues
• A monsoon flood or fire damages the property
• You need to cover lost rental income during repairs

The Arizona Reality: Arizona's unique risks—including flash floods, monsoons, extreme heat, and occasional freezing—require specialized coverage beyond basic policies.

4. The "I'll Figure Out the Laws Later" Legal Oversight

Arizona has specific landlord-tenant laws that differ from other states. Landlords who ignore these regulations face:

• Costly legal battles with tenants
• Unenforceable lease terms
• Improper eviction proceedings that get thrown out of court

The Arizona Reality: The Arizona Residential Landlord and Tenant Act outlines specific requirements for security deposits (must be returned within 14 days), entry notices (at least 2 days required), and maintenance responsibilities. Plus, significant changes are coming in 2025, including the abolition of residential rental taxes effective January 1, 2025.

5. The "Set It and Forget It" Management Mindset

Perhaps the costliest mistake is assuming rental properties run themselves. This hands-off approach leads to:

• Undetected property damage that worsens over time
• Tenant issues that escalate into major problems
• Missed opportunities to adjust rents with the market

The Arizona Reality: Arizona's rental market varies significantly by location, and professional management typically delivers 8-12% higher returns despite their fees because of better tenant selection, reduced vacancies, and proper maintenance.

How KPI Realtors Protect Your Investment

Our comprehensive property management services shield you from these costly mistakes. We handle:

• Thorough tenant screening that complies with all regulations
• Professional maintenance with our network of trusted contractors
• Proper insurance guidance specific to Arizona properties
• Legal compliance with all Arizona landlord-tenant laws
• Regular inspections and proactive management

Don't Learn These Lessons the Hard Way

While managing your property might seem like a money-saving decision, the true costs of DIY management often far exceed professional management fees.

Ready to protect your investment? Contact KPI Realtors today to learn how our property management services can safeguard your rental property and maximize your returns.

​Ready for professional help? Contact KPI Realtors today and let us handle the headaches while you enjoy the returns.

Contact us for expert property management services1